| « Positive Deviance | Conversations in Project Management » |
The Scientific Method and Project Management
Project Management, Project Management Methodology, Project Planning, Project Reporting, Project Scope ManagementSource - Article by Bob Andrew

The scientific method is what keeps scientists busy and earns them a living. Using established principles and processes of discovery and demonstration, they observe nature and physical phenomena, formulate hypotheses to explain the phenomena, experiment by means of repeatable tests to show the truth or falseness of the hypotheses, validate or modify the hypotheses and then share their data with other scientists. If an hypothesis remains proven, by successfully being tested or applied over a period of time, it can become a theory. Theories can then be combined to derive a coherent and supportive structure. Scientists use the scientific method to search for cause and effect relationships in nature. In this way their experiments are designed in such a way to see what changes to one item cause some other item to vary in a predictable way.
The scientific method is unemotional and impersonal. The only chance for real success in science is to describe the evidence without regard to the way you feel it should be. The good and bad parts of a theory have to be explained impartially. As the famous Nobel Physics prize winner, Richard Feynman, stated: "Science is a way of trying not to fool yourself. The first principle is that you must not fool yourself, and you are the easiest person to fool. Science is what we do to prevent us lying to ourselves.”

The body of scientific knowledge at any point in history, including now, is simply the collection of theories and views of the world that have not yet been shown to be wrong. Somewhat flippantly, compare this to the project management body of knowledge, which does not consist of theories but consists mainly of various methodologies and procedures. Based on documented records of project management performance, it would be untrue to say that the current body of project management knowledge represents views that have not yet shown to be wrong.
...
One of the reasons that the scientific method has been so successful is that scientists recognise that personal and cultural beliefs can influence both perceptions and interpretations of natural phenomena and for this reason, always aim to minimise those influences when developing a theory through the use of standard procedures and criteria. In summary, the scientific method attempts to minimise the influence of bias or prejudice in the experimenter when testing an hypothesis or a theory. As a famous scientist once said, "Smart people (like smart lawyers) can come up with very good explanations for mistaken points of view."
Project performance targets can be related to the scientific method by cause and effect relationships. Performance targets can be viewed as the effects, and applying the scientific method would relate to identifying the variables over which the project team has control that will cause these desired effects. As a scientist would do, the project manager needs to first articulate ideas as to how the outcome of the project management tasks and activities (experiments: plan-do-check) will produce the desired effects. For example, in scientific terms, a project plan is an experiment to see what you don’t understand about the work. In doing this, the project manager will avoid the situation where projects are completed on time and within budget, but fall short in the performance requirements: ‘the project was done right, but it was not the right project’.
The setting of clear performance targets and measurement methods is closely aligned with the disciplines of scientific statistical design of experiments and is equally relevant to project management. Clear and unambiguous targets are required for project success. Stating and documenting clear performance targets are the prime means of project scope control and performance targets are a starting point for implementation of the scientific method.
The scientific method is also focused on avoiding the so-called Dunning-Kruger effect, where unskilled people make poor decisions and reach wrong conclusions, but cannot recognise their mistakes due to their incompetence. Unlike highly skilled and competent people, who generally underrate their level of competency, people affected by the Dunning-Kruger effect rate their skills very highly and have high levels of misguided self confidence, which can have a negative effect on the design and implementation of project tasks and activities. The Dunning-Kruger effect is a scientific elaboration on a famous quote by Charles Darwin that ‘ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge’. The importance of skills and knowledge, and especially the avoidance of ‘knowledge gaps’ is a strong feature of the scientific method.
An important aspect of the scientific method in relation to its value for project management, is objectivity and avoidance of biased interpretations of results. Another is the emphasis given to documentation, archiving and sharing of all data and methodologies so that they are available for scrutiny by other scientists. This practice, called full disclosure, allows statistical measures of the reliability of the data to be established. This may seem an unlikely practice in the competitive world of business and projects, but the principles are nevertheless worth noting.
19 comments
-
§ Payday Loans Online said on : 11/11/10 @ 13:50
Can you write another post about this topic because this post was a bit difficult to fully grasp?
-
§ abnehmtabletten said on : 11/19/10 @ 08:28
You made some good points there. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog.
-
§ wipsusa said on : 12/05/10 @ 03:52
Hey, I'm going to email this to my associates. I came on this while searching on aol thanks for sharing.
-
§ Jeanne Mc Donald
said on : 12/09/10 @ 10:38
What a great article! Couldn't have put it better myself. -
§ Bonusy Kasyna said on : 12/18/10 @ 11:54
Interesting article. Were did you got all the information from?
-
§ wózki wielofunkcyjne dla dzieci said on : 12/22/10 @ 17:08
Great article, would be more of these on the Web! I will be a constant reader of this page!
-
§ live poker game said on : 01/25/11 @ 20:24
Nice post. Thanks for sharing. Keep it up!
-
§ Get Backlinks said on : 01/25/11 @ 23:19
Interesting thoughts on your blog, can i ask where you got your colors from?
-
§ bundesliga poker said on : 01/26/11 @ 18:46
You are professional.
-
§ gratis online pokern said on : 01/28/11 @ 06:02
Hi there, I just needed to state how interesting I find this blog!
-
§ Larry page new ceo said on : 02/01/11 @ 15:49
Constructive criticism is generally looked upon as becoming politically incorrect.
-
§ Bonusy Powitalne Kasyno said on : 02/06/11 @ 14:49
Outstanding piece, thanks for sharing!
-
§ Bebe Chadek said on : 02/06/11 @ 20:12
You made some clear points there. I looked on the internet for the subject matter and found most people will agree with your site.
-
§ The Newest Hair Loss Home Remedies For You said on : 02/07/11 @ 07:42
Well I really liked studying it. This post provided by you is very effective for proper planning.
-
§ Efficient Hair Loss Home Remedies For You said on : 02/09/11 @ 21:17
Awsome website! I am loving it!! Will come back again. I am taking your feeds also
-
§ Lakita Gemmer said on : 02/13/11 @ 06:35
Hi, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog site in Opera, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, wonderful blog!
-
§ Your Back Pain Diet said on : 02/23/11 @ 22:02
For instance on mine I've 1 individual who also writes poetry besides me.
-
§ 7 Seconds Pain Relief said on : 02/24/11 @ 00:54
Condense! I believe it would be a lot more efficient if presented better.
-
§ Sexiest Date said on : 02/24/11 @ 02:36
My mom is amazingly talented at composing. She has been hearing this her whole life long. She disregards all this. I have finally convinced her to begin composing on the web-just for self-expression. Any idea of the best forum? She normally writes of her own experiences.How does 1 produce a weblog? What's required to be done?
This post has 5 feedbacks awaiting moderation...
Recent comments